The group determined no staff was unequivocally higher than the opposite. So it went to its listing of protocols, selecting the Sooners primarily based on their convention championship. In hindsight, it ought to have been pretty apparent that is what they’d find yourself doing, contemplating they telegraphed their transfer final Tuesday, rating Oklahoma forward of Ohio State.
Georgia practically pulling the upset on No. 1 Alabama could have difficult issues slightly, however the reality is, the committee would have set a daring precedent had it put in a two-loss, non-conference champion into the playoff over two convention champions with one loss apiece.
However that is faculty soccer, so the arguments will not cease now that the highest 4 have been chosen. And that argument all begins with this: Are the No. four Sooners the very best staff among the many trio?
That’s the place we welcome again the great outdated “greatest vs. most deserving” argument that dominates nearly each playoff choice day. On this case, it took practically a complete season to revisit what it means, precisely, to be among the finest 4 groups, or one of many 4 most deserving groups to play for a nationwide championship.
That is precisely why the choice committee has protocols to comply with, beginning with giving weight to convention champions. Georgia could have seemed like one of many 4 greatest groups within the nation for 55 minutes within the SEC championship sport, however all issues being equal, a convention championship ought to matter.
If Georgia had solely that one loss to No. 1 Alabama on its resume, you can soundly make an argument that the Bulldogs have been among the many greatest AND essentially the most deserving. It is the identical argument that helped non-champion Alabama make the playoff final 12 months forward of Massive Ten champion Ohio State.
However right here is the largest consider all of this: Georgia, like Ohio State final 12 months, had two losses. Georgia, in contrast to Ohio State final 12 months, didn’t have a convention championship. So why would a two-loss non-champion Georgia staff make it on this 12 months when a two-loss champion Ohio State staff didn’t a 12 months in the past?
Ultimately, it is that second loss that was too exhausting to disregard.
Georgia misplaced on the street to No. 11 LSU by 20 factors, and was merely non-competitive within the sport.
Had the committee put Georgia in, three Energy 5 champions (together with two with one loss every) would have been unnoticed. So what does that say about how a lot each sport issues in faculty soccer, how the common season is essentially the most thrilling in all of sports activities? It is a precedent that might have benefitted solely the highly effective SEC, and would have greater than possible pushed playoff enlargement to the forefront not simply amongst these within the UCF camp however these within the Massive Ten and Massive 12 camps as effectively.
Maybe enlargement is an inevitability in the long run — at the least then, a staff that is gained 25 video games in a row like UCF would possibly even have a shot at enjoying for a championship. However for proper now, the committee needed to comply with its protocols when introduced with the very best vs. deserving argument. As committee chairman Rob Mullens stated on ESPN, there was no argument that one staff amongst these three was unequivocally higher than the opposite.
So it went to its listing of standards, beginning with convention championships.
“On this occasion, when one staff wasn’t unequivocally higher than the opposite, the one-loss convention champion carried the day,” Mullens stated.
The one shock in all this was the place the committee ranked Georgia, at No. 5 forward of one-loss convention champion Ohio State. That alerts there was a powerful, strong debate, one which the committee felt comfy having. As a result of Georgia does seem like among the finest groups within the nation. Actually, hypothetical spreads in Las Vegas have Georgia as a 6.5-point favourite in opposition to Ohio State, and a 3.5-point favourite in opposition to Oklahoma.
However the committee was merely not able to make such a daring determination, that might have had ripple-effects not simply on this 12 months’s playoff, however for the complete sport on the whole. Physique of labor has to matter. Profitable video games has to matter. Maybe sooner or later a two-loss staff will discover its manner into the playoff, but it surely’s exhausting to make that argument with no convention championship to indicate for it. Ohio State tried it final 12 months and failed.
As for the Buckeyes, there’s a beneficial lesson to be taken from developing simply quick the final two seasons. Profitable convention championships imply an amazing deal — as long as there is not a blowout loss to an unranked staff to associate with it. The loss to Purdue this 12 months and Iowa final 12 months submarined any possibilities they’d on the prime 4.
Whether or not they need to be forward of Georgia is irrelevant. Solely the highest 4 matter within the race to make the playoff. And the committee made the best name as soon as once more.