LS polls: Mamata takes politics of grievance too far in West Bengal, permits Modi and Shah to show tables

0 1

Grievance is grist for nice politics. Its consummate cultivation as an artwork is a uncommon talent that West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee has perfected to the hilt. Recall the visible of a younger Mamata being dragged out from the Writer’s Building, the state secretariat, by Jyoti Basu’s administration in 1993 when she was a junior minister within the PV Narasimha Rao authorities.

She nursed that grievance and efficiently channelised it into her politics. In her state, the place the Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPM) had advanced a vicious pressure of statecraft that was authoritarian to the core, Banerjee was seen as an efficient antidote. It was not with out motive that she bought the primary congratulatory message from her Gujarat counterpart, Narendra Modi, after her first electoral victory within the West Bengal Assembly in 2011. At the time, Modi additionally checked out her as a loner who fought relentlessly to create her personal area in opposition to a cadre-based robust political celebration. She confirmed the potential of an important chief within the making.

File picture of West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee. PTI

But Banerjee didn’t realise the truth that politics of perpetual grievance creates its personal antidotes and has extreme limitations. Since her ascension to energy in 2011, she couldn’t evolve within the position of an efficient administrator whose governance just isn’t constrained by politics. In February, she tried to intimidate CBI officers and stall the inquiry in opposition to IPS officer Rajeev Kumar — her favorite — within the Saradha chit-fund rip-off. She not solely went on a quick in opposition to the CBI,but in addition inspired the IPS officer to affix her. For the primary time, the chief government of a state was egging on and inspiring riot in opposition to the State.

This was adopted up by the slapping of legal circumstances in opposition to officers of the CBI posted in Kolkata by the state police. The retribution in opposition to the central company was a transparent violation of the constitutional association of a federal construction. Yet, Banerjee bought away with this indiscretion with none rap on her knuckles. She was additional emboldened to declare that the state wouldn’t let the central companies perform. As a consequence, the state police began interfering with customs officers at Kolkata airport and compelled them to not take motion in opposition to the spouse of a Trinamool Congress chief reportedly caught with contraband.

In impact, Banerjee appears to be taking her politics of grievance a bit too far. Short of declaring West Bengal a separate republic, she has been defying all tenets of the Constitution on the pretext of preventing ‘communal forces’ represented by the BJP, which has changed the Congress and the CPM as the principle Opposition within the state. Her stranglehold over the state paperwork and co-option of criminals within the cadre have mixed to present a sense of déjà vu for individuals of the state. The Trinamool Congress acquired the options of a lumpenised CPM.

Like the CPM, which grossly underestimated Banerjee’s problem, she  has grossly overestimated garrulousness as her political energy and trusted her instincts greater than a well-crafted political technique. Given the demographic change that occurred within the border districts of West Bengal, she appeared to have ignored simmering social discontent and communal fault strains. This social discontent was additional accentuated by her picture as a frontrunner who pursues anti-industry insurance policies, a truth borne out by her opposition to industrial tasks in Singur and Nandigram.

As the final spherical of polls attracts close to and West Bengal is within the eye of a storm, there is no such thing as a doubt that Banerjee will need to have been aware of the fact that her evaluation of Modi and BJP president Amit Shah has gone horribly incorrect. The motive is apparent. During her NDA years, she was fairly adept in coping with leaders like Atal Bihari Vajpayee and LK Advani and located them fairly amenable to her tantrums. There have been cases when she raised a banner of revolt in opposition to the BJP management, however maintained cordial ties with each prime BJP leaders.

In the NDA authorities, she compelled Vajpayee’s hand and had George Fernandes eliminated as defence minister within the Tehelka bribery case. That led to en masse resignation of the JD(U) cupboard members. Apparently Vajpayee and Advani checked out Banerjee as a possible ally in West Bengal the place the BJP was non-existent and but didn’t have political ambitions for the state both.

However, the Modi-Shah duo modified the sport and located a political vacuum ready to be stuffed by the BJP. Grievances that have been as soon as Banerjee’s weapon turned an efficient instrument for the BJP, which expanded its organisational community by co-opting ‘notables’ or well-known personalities and celebrities in addition to skilled political cadres who drifted away both from the Congress or the CPM.

Within the previous 5 years, the celebration has constructed a formidable organisation suitably bolstered by the central management to mount an efficient problem to Banerjee. Her indiscretions and her dismal governance proved to be a catalyst for the BJP’s mobilisation of individuals on grievances. In essence, she has discovered greater than a match within the Modi-Shah duo.

Follow all news from the Lok Sabha Election 2019 campaign here


<!– Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the most recent evaluation, commentary and information updates, join our WhatsApp companies. Just go to and hit the Subscribe button.

Your information to the most recent election information, evaluation, commentary, reside updates and schedule for Lok Sabha Elections 2019 on Follow us on Twitter and Instagram or like our Facebook web page for updates from all 543 constituencies for the upcoming normal elections.

Source link

style="display:block" data-ad-format="autorelaxed" data-ad-client="ca-pub-7215484115719870" data-ad-slot="3748692187">
Facebook Comments