How Legion’s Professor X Compares To X-Men Movie Versions
Legion has lastly revealed its model of the long-lasting mutant Professor X – however how does he evaluate to his X-Men film counterparts performed by Patrick Stewart and James McAvoy? In Legion, Charles Xavier is the organic father of David Haller, the present’s ultra-powerful mutant protagonist (or antagonist, relying on the place we’re within the story). For its first two seasons, Xavier was by no means straight evoked, however hinted at via some acquainted imagery, like an empty wheelchair. But for Legion’s ultimate season, the person himself will probably be making an look. Games of Thrones and Doctor Who alum Harry Lloyd appeared because the well-known mutant telepath – sporting a full head of hair – within the season’s third episode, a flashback sequence telling the surprisingly unhappy story of how David’s mother and father fell in love.
We clearly have solely spent one episode with Lloyd’s Xavier, but it surely’s already simple to see there are some vital variations between this model and the film variations. The greatest distinction is the obvious – this model of Xavier is the daddy of David Haller. This is just not one thing Legion simply conjured up; David Haller was a vital determine within the X-Men comics within the 90s, serving as a catalyst for the line-wide Age of Apocalypse occasion. It’s a situation wealthy with potentialities, and maintaining Xavier off the board till the story’s climax was an impressed alternative for Legion. It’s doable the movie variations of Xavier might have fathered a toddler with Gabrielle Haller, however there was by no means any indication of that. This is a facet of the character that the movies by no means explored, which isn’t shocking. Legion is a darkish, intimate story that would not have labored in a two-hour blockbuster, squeezed in between scenes of Wolverine stabbing individuals and Dark Phoenix scowling.
This model of Xavier additionally exists in a special period than the film variations. While the X-Men movies have all the time performed it quick and unfastened with its personal continuity, Stewart and McAvoy are ostensibly portraying the identical model of the character, who was seen in X-Men: First Class to be a person in his mid-20s by 1961. In Legion, Xavier fought in World War II at about the identical age, twenty years sooner than the movie model. This Xavier was deeply affected by the horrors he endured through the conflict, which led him to a post-war psychiatric ward. Xavier did not suppose a lot of the docs, however used his time there to assist others via their points together with his psychic talents, together with Gabrielle Haller. Charles and Gabrielle would fall in love, and Xavier altered the minds of the psych ward docs to rearrange their early launch so they might begin their lives collectively. Unfortunately, that little little bit of hubris on Xavier’s half my show to be his broken son’s undoing.
Despite the very fact he is the benevolent face of mutantkind, Xavier has by no means been a morally pure character, which has all the time held true within the stay motion variations as nicely. Stewart’s Professor X made some ethically questionable selections relating to Wolverine and Jean Grey, and McAvoy’s Xavier was such a continuing, egocentric screwup that it was sometimes obscure why anybody would observe the man. This is unquestionably the case with Lloyd’s Xavier, who makes fast, self-serving choices with out considering via the doable penalties. It would appear that value him his spouse, and will find yourself costing David his life.
There’s nonetheless so much we do not learn about Legion’s model of Charles Xavier. There’s been no trace that the X-Men exist, or that Xavier even began a faculty for mutants. Also, one other surprisingly darkish situation is beginning to appear increasingly probably. In the comics, Xavier by no means knew about his son till he was an grownup, but it surely’s beginning to appear extremely unbelievable that Xavier did not know this model of David. He raised him at the very least for a short time with Gabrielle earlier than the Shadow King took maintain, and we have nonetheless not seen the precise fallout from that. But most significantly, will we lastly get to see David confront the person who deserted him as an toddler, damning him to years of psychic torture? It’s the largest query Legion has but to resolve, and the reply is probably going coming because the collection hurtles towards its conclusion.