Good Residence Diary: An replace to our blinds revealing that Alexa isn’t any smarter than Siri

I’ve performed round a bit with Alexa, and even thought-about shopping for an Echo Dot or two earlier than...

· 8 min read >
Smart Home Diary: An update to our blinds revealing that Alexa is no smarter than Siri
I’ve performed round a bit with Alexa, and even thought-about shopping for an Echo Dot or two earlier than the launch of HomePod, however ultimately determined to attend it out.

Nevertheless, whereas Hunter Douglas continues to be promising HomeKit help for our Luxaflex Duette blinds, and was anticipating to get there by now, certification has been delayed till later within the yr. Within the meantime, it’s gone forward with the launch of the brand new bridge which brings voice management to the blinds – however up to now just for Alexa and Google Residence …


Moderately than look ahead to HomeKit, we determined to get an Amazon Echo Dot as an interim answer – which additionally supplied a possibility to pit Siri towards Alexa in a real-life good speaker check.

Notice that I say ‘Siri versus Alexa,’ not HomePod versus Echo Dot. As audio system, the 2 units aren’t even in the identical league. HomePod is a $349 machine which will get into what I consider as semi-HiFi territory. It doesn’t compete with conventional HiFi manufacturers, however is definitely into Sonos territory. Certainly, one replaced the Sonos Play 5 in our bed room. Echo Dot is a tiny $50 (or less) speaker supposed to be simply sufficient for voice responses. You’ll be able to play music by means of it, however I actually wouldn’t advocate it!

This piece isn’t a complete evaluation of the Echo Dot. Moderately, it’s an overview of my experiences utilizing it as an interim machine for management of our blinds – and the extra taking part in I did out of curiosity.

However let’s begin with how Alexa handles common queries, as a result of that is one space the place it’s seemingly smarter than Siri – however in actuality, not a lot …

Common queries

Alexa principally works on the idea of downloadable ‘expertise.’ On the plus aspect, which means its capabilities are infinitely expandable, and that anybody can add to Alexa’s expertise, not simply Amazon.

However there are two very huge issues with this method. First, as a result of anybody can add a ability, there are many competing expertise for issues like public transit standing – in London, the tube. There doesn’t seem like an official Transport for London ability, so I used to be left putting in, attempting after which uninstalling random ones till I discovered one.

However the greater drawback is that, even with a ability enabled, you’ll be able to’t ask pure questions like ‘Is the Circle Line operating okay?’. As a substitute, it’s important to ask Alexa to ask the ability. The format for these queries is:

Alexa, ask  

For instance:

Alexa, ask London Journey whether or not the Circle Line is operating

That’s not solely horrendously clunky, but in addition ridiculously unscalable. Even with only a handful of expertise enabled, I couldn’t bear in mind the following day whether or not the tube one was referred to as London Transport or London Tubes or London Journey – partially, as a result of I’d needed to strive a number of of them earlier than discovering one which labored effectively.

My associate was additionally merrily utilizing Alexa so as to add issues to a purchasing basket, considering she was doing so on Ocado by saying ‘Alexa, add to our Ocado purchasing checklist’ solely to search out that she had merely created an Amazon purchasing checklist referred to as Ocado. It’s a must to say ‘Alexa, inform Ocado so as to add to basket.’

After getting a couple of dozen expertise put in, there’s not an opportunity in hell that you just’ll ever bear in mind all their names – particularly those you utilize sometimes.

So the theoretical benefit of Alexa, that it may well do very way more, is simply that: theoretical. In follow, as soon as I’d completed taking part in with it, I discovered that I solely actually used the PowerView, Neato and Ocado expertise. Plus, Amazon might be happy to listen to, ordering from Amazon.

Alexa can be dumber than Siri when you could have a couple of machine: all Alexa-enabled units inside earshot concurrently reply, quite than Siri’s methodology of 1 machine answering and the remaining standing down.

The Alexa iOS app

There’s an extra drawback with downloadable expertise: it’s important to set up these through the Alexa iOS app.

It’s no exaggeration to say that the Alexa app is without doubt one of the worst apps it has ever been my misfortune to make use of. It’s an absolute mess of random placement and non-obvious approaches to doing issues. It appears to be like prefer it was designed by a roomful of monkeys on crack. I cringe or swear each time I’ve to make use of it.

And it’s this similar app it’s important to use to allow good residence management …

Good residence management

Like Siri, Alexa can management your good residence units. Its huge benefit right here is that Amazon makes it very simple for machine producers to allow Alexa, so virtually something you’ll be able to title could be Alexa-controlled. Siri, in distinction, is proscribed to HomeKit-compatible units, and people should be individually licensed by Apple.

There’s good cause for that, after all: Apple locations a excessive worth on safety, so all merchandise have to satisfy Apple’s requirements earlier than they’re authorized. However that could be a ache for shoppers. For us, it’s at all times felt like a ache that we are able to management all our lights by voice, however should depend on a mixture of timed automations and iPhone management for the blinds. Greater than as soon as, I’ve caught myself about to instruct Siri to open or shut a blind earlier than remembering that she will’t do this but.

There are a couple of bits of dangerous information with the Alexa arrange course of for the blinds. First, since you want a brand new bridge, it’s important to fully configure the blinds from scratch. That’s not tough, however it’s tedious if in case you have numerous them.

Second, Alexa can’t management particular person blinds, it may well solely activate scenes. Which means that when you do need to have the ability to open or shut a single blind, it’s important to create a scene for it first. Once more, not an enormous deal, however a bit clunky.

Third, it’s important to use the terrible Alexa iOS app to allow management. You create your scenes within the PowerView app as ordinary, after which have to enter the PowerView ability throughout the Alexa app and, counter-intuitively, inform it so as to add a scene. Once you do this, it goes in search of scenes in PowerView and provides them to its personal checklist. That achieved, you should utilize them.

However as soon as it’s achieved, the excellent news is that you just don’t have to make use of the clunky ‘Ask PowerView to …’ format. The Alexa app has a separate part for good residence performance, and there you’ll be able to simply use the identical instructions you would for Siri.

The precise phrasing for management of the blinds nonetheless isn’t 100% intuitive. You’ll be able to’t say one thing like ‘Morning, blinds.’ You as an alternative should say ‘Swap on morning.’ However when you’re used to this, it’s easy sufficient.

For Hue lights, Alexa management is an identical to Siri management. I took to randomly utilizing one or the opposite to modify lights on and off, and located no distinction between them in language, velocity or reliability.

Our robotic vacuum cleaner, the Neato Botvac D7 Linked, can be Alexa-enabled. Largely that’s no nice profit, as weekdays it runs on an automatic schedule, doing the cleansing at 8.40am. However at weekends, we run it once we’re out of the way in which, and for these instances it’s useful to have the ability to say ‘Alexa, ask Neato to start out cleansing.’ Extra on that phrasing later …

Timers and different reminders

We use Siri quite a bit for timers and different reminders. Pre-iOS 12, Siri famously can solely run one timer at a time – whereas Alexa fortunately handles a number of timers.

Information and climate

For information, Alexa provides a Every day Briefing, together with your alternative of supply. Within the UK, that defaulted to BBC Information, which might have been my alternative, and it might be a useful catchup for anybody who’s a bit out of contact. For a information junkie like me, it’s much less helpful.

Alexa had a giant fail when it got here to climate. It supplied climate for a random earlier handle, and didn’t appear eager on altering that reality. It appeared odd that I used to be related to Alexa utilizing my Amazon ID – which clearly has my present handle – however the Alexa app didn’t have my handle pre-populated. Even after I entered it, it continued to present climate for the previous handle, till I discovered a second place to enter my handle. That roomful of monkeys actually must be fired.


We do most of our purchasing on-line, groceries from Ocado, most different issues from Amazon.

Right here, Alexa is unbelievable. I informed Alexa ‘Order a Sodastream spare fuel cylinder.’ It noticed I’d ordered one from Amazon earlier than, confirmed the main points and worth and requested me if I wished to order one. I replied ‘sure’ and Alexa confirmed the order and informed me it might arrive tomorrow.

Equally, I informed Alexa ‘Ask Ocado so as to add kitchen roll to my purchasing trolley.’ Alexa used my favorites to decide on which model, and once more suggested particulars and worth earlier than asking me to substantiate.

This expertise is really nice. I hate purchasing, and discover even on-line purchasing a chore, so this can be a completely painless approach to do it. I’d purchase an Echo Dot only for this.

Third-party audio system

One other benefit of Alexa over Siri is that Amazon permits third-party audio system and headphones to help the platform, so you could have a huge choice of Alexa-enabled speakers from a variety of manufacturers. These vary from the Echo Dot to Sonos and Harman Kardon.

I attempted a beautiful speaker from Cavalier called the Maverick. That is roughly the identical measurement as the primary Amazon Echo speaker, however a quite extra premium expertise. The sound high quality is remarkably good for a speaker of this measurement. It delivers a complete of 20W output with two energetic drivers offering stereo, and two passive radiators delivering approach extra bass than a speaker of this measurement has any proper to.

With a steel casing coupled to leather-based and cloth, the feel and appear is leagues above the Echo too. It has a fantastically weighted rotary quantity management on the highest. The panel can be touch-sensitive, with the standard sample of controls by default: faucet as soon as for play/pause, twice for next-track and thrice for earlier observe. However the double- and triple-taps are configurable within the app.

Sat on a desk or worktop, you wouldn’t guess the opposite key advantage of this over the Echo: the Cavalier is battery-powered. It lifts off its charging base, and also you then have a speaker you’ll be able to carry to a different room or use open air.

As you’d count on, it’s additionally much more costly than the Amazon Echo, at $299 quite than $99 (or much less), however it’s in a distinct league. I’m fairly fussy about my audio system, however for a speaker of this measurement, I actually can’t fault it.


I’d totally anticipated Alexa to be significantly smarter than Siri. The truth that Amazon lets anybody create a ability for its clever assistant signifies that it must be massively extra succesful.

And in concept, it’s. However the clunky methodology of including expertise to the machine signifies that, in follow, no one goes so as to add greater than the necessities. In order that theoretical benefit is nugatory in follow.

The one space the place it does win out is controlling good residence units. Alexa can management our lights, blinds and robotic vacuum cleaner; Siri, solely our lights.

In some instances, that’s a brief benefit. Hunter Douglas assures me that HomeKit help is on the way in which, but it surely’s nonetheless annoying to have to attend so lengthy for it to reach. I actually suppose Apple must streamline the method of testing and approving merchandise for HomeKit help.

However in different instances, it’s a everlasting win for Alexa. Apple’s approvals course of is nice for conserving our houses safe, and I wouldn’t wish to see that compromised, however the hoops by means of which producers want to leap signifies that many merely gained’t hassle. There are at all times going to be units which Alexa can management however Siri can’t.

In the end, although, voice management of devices is an interim stage. We already use automated schedules for lots of issues (together with routine opening and shutting of blinds), and good houses will regularly get smarter, to allow them to work out extra of what we’d like from our patterns of conduct. In some unspecified time in the future, the necessity to ask both Siri or Alexa to do one thing would be the exception quite than the rule.

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:


Facebook Comments