Dropping MS Dhoni, the wicket-keeper, with out grooming appropriate understudy a flawed transfer by nationwide selectors


The dilemma on the coronary heart of Indian cricket’s present points is: Is there life after 37? Nearly everybody — from cricket followers to media to selectors — is obsessive about that single poser at any time when a sure Mahendra Singh Dhoni is talked about.

At 37, within the night of a really excellent profession, Dhoni is actually underneath the microscope the place his each innings, stroke, and method is extremely studied with the intention of announcing him over the hill. Whether or not such an evaluation is untimely or not, solely time will inform.

Dhoni continues to be the perfect wicket-keeper in India, as his catch to dismiss Chandrapaul Hemraj in Pune illustrates.

Nevertheless, the grim actuality is that the nationwide selectors and crew administration have twin targets to concentrate on. And each run parallel to one another. It’s the trajectory to those targets that’s the crux of L‘affair Dhoni.

The targets are throughout two time zones: the ICC World Cup (50 overs) scheduled to be held in England from late Might 2019 and the World T20 Championship in Australia from mid-October 2020. The selectors’ accountability is to make use of the subsequent few months to prepared a pool of probables for these occasions.

Whereas the final consensus is that Dhoni could be good for the 2019 World Cup, the 2020 World T20 is one thing else altogether. The occasion shouldn’t be solely two years away, however there’s each likelihood that Dhoni’s physique wouldn’t be capable to stand up to the damage and tear of the sport till then.

Thus, quite than banking completely on Dhoni, the selectors wish to rapidly unearth a second lot of wicket-keepers.

Sadly, they don’t appear to have zeroed in on Rishabh Pant to work as an understudy; as a substitute, they’ve fallen again on 33-year-old Dinesh Karthik (T20I debut in 2006) as his back-up for the T20Is in opposition to Australia.

Whether or not it is a clever transfer or not will play out solely later. Nevertheless, it definitely doesn’t say a lot for the selectors’ confidence in Pant’s wicket-keeping abilities. Why else would they wish to maintain a extremely skilled veteran on the bench? Wouldn’t it not have been less complicated to have a younger understudy to carry out that function, particularly if Pant was the automated selection as wicket-keeper?

It’s in opposition to this background that the dropping of Dhoni for the T20Is in Australia subsequent month should be seen.

It’s no one’s case that Dhoni must play past his ‘use-by’ date, which certainly should be only a event or two away. However the appropriate approach would have been to discover a teen ok to push him out of the crew or for Dhoni himself to carry out so badly in his main job that the crew had little use for him.

Nevertheless, neither is the case. Dhoni continues to be India’s primary wicket-keeper by an extended margin. Pant’s wicket-keeping abilities aren’t a patch on Dhoni’s.

Dhoni, in actual fact, proved within the third ODI in opposition to the West Indies that he was a reduce above all his rivals. The sprinting, diving catch he took to dismiss Chandrapaul Hemraj was the type that different wicket-keepers on the tour to Australia, Pant, Karthik or Check squad member, Parthiv Patel, won’t even have even tried, not to mention take. Then there was that lighting stumping off Kuldeep Yadav which was an absolute peach.

Thus the place his wicket-keeping is worried Dhoni’s efficiency belies his 37 years of age. His batting although is a bit totally different.

Dhoni is now not the ace finisher he was even two to 3 years in the past. He won’t even be the large hitter of the previous. However then that is to be anticipated. Viv Richards, the best batsman since Don Bradman, moved down the batting order, from quantity three to quantity 5, in the course of the tail finish of his profession. He had slowed down and was now not feared because the grasp blaster of yore. India’s Sachin Tendulkar too was not as devastating with the bat in the direction of the final section of his profession.

The truth is, if the 37-year-old muscle tissues don’t ache after a stint of wicket-keeping, Dhoni might nonetheless be the perfect guess for India at quantity 4 in ODIs. He might bat at his tempo and add solidity to that spot.

However then, the onus at this level of time is on Dhoni’s profession in T20Is. It’s right here that India should swiftly discover the appropriate substitute. Dhoni himself has two editions of IPL (2019 and 2020) to point out that there’s nonetheless some T20 life left in him.

In fact, two years is a very long time in cricket. The selectors have taken the primary tiny steps in the direction of discovering any person to fill Dhoni’s huge footwear. Till they try this or Dhoni himself bows out, the final of this subject has not been heard.


Revealed Date: October 29, 2018

| Up to date Date: October 29, 2018


Up to date Date: Oct 29, 2018


style="display:block" data-ad-format="autorelaxed" data-ad-client="ca-pub-7215484115719870" data-ad-slot="3748692187">
Facebook Comments