Warning: SPOILERS ahead for Dark Phoenix

Dark Phoenix deserved higher than the brutal critiques it obtained from critics and its failure on the field workplace. Writer-director Simon Kinberg’s movie presently stands at 23% on Rotten Tomatoes and, partly on account of the adverse phrase of mouth, Fox’s ultimate X-Men movie is predicted to lose $100-million. This definitely is not how anybody wished the X-Men franchise to finish. Box workplace efficiency and demanding reactions apart, nonetheless, the precise movie itself shouldn’t be the catastrophe its Rotten Tomatoes rating signifies.

On paper, the plan for Dark Phoenix made sense. Like the followers, Kinberg was nonetheless smarting from how poorly Brett Ratner’s X-Men: The Last Stand (which he co-wrote) tailored Marvel Comics’ The Dark Phoenix Saga, relegating it to the movie’s B-plot and making it extra about Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) than Jean Grey (Famke Janssen). Now that he had inventive management of the X-Men, Kinberg wished to make his adaptation more true to the comics, together with the cosmic points of the story: the Phoenix Force was an influence supply from outer area that bonded with Jean, the X-Men would go into outer area, and there can be aliens for the mutants to battle. Kinberg additionally had a younger forged, led by Game of ThronesSophie Turner as Jean, to utterly distinguish the film from The Last Stand.

Continue scrolling to maintain studying Click the button beneath to begin this text in fast view.

Related: Dark Phoenix’s Reshoots Explained: Every Change Made To Fox’s Final X-Men Movie

Instead of a full-blown adaptation of the comics, Kinberg deliberate a extra intimate movie about Jean’s fracturing psyche and the X-Men breaking up due to her, with some nods to the unique story’s cosmic parts. But as soon as the primary trailer was launched within the fall of 2018, it was evident that Dark Phoenix still looked and felt too much like X-Men: The Last Stand and would not be a brand new or completely different type of X-Men film, so followers have been already upset. Dark Phoenix wasn’t simply up in opposition to followers’ dangerous reminiscences of X-Men: The Last Stand; its June 2019 launch date positioned it proper on the heels of Captain Marvel and Avengers: Endgame, each of which have been monumental successes for Marvel Studios that critics and followers adored (particularly Endgame).

All instructed, Dark Phoenix had an unimaginable quantity of production issues, reshoots, delays, and circumstances past the inventive crew’s management (particularly, the acquisition of Fox by Disney). These mixed issues can be insurmountable for any movie. and Dark Phoenix was no exception. In reality, the film is not fairly all the things it might (or ought to) have been. But, if it is attainable to take away the movie from the points surrounding its launch and the strain it was below to carry out regardless of all of it, Dark Phoenix is definitely a much better movie than its low mixture Rotten Tomatoes score signifies.

Dark Phoenix Negativity Came From Years of Build Up

<!–[if IE 9]><![endif]–>Sophie Turner in Dark Phoenix poster

After critics and followers had skilled years of adverse build-up to Dark Phoenix, the movie itself would have wanted to be undeniably improbable to beat the dangerous buzz. It’s truthful to invest that lots of people’s minds have been already largely made up that Dark Phoenix was a catastrophe, sight unseen. And, when Dark Phoenix proved to be lower than spectacular, that simply cemented the pre-determined opinion that the film was destined to be a bomb. The field workplace outcomes proved that proper, since many followers heeded the bad reviews and determined Dark Phoenix wasn’t price seeing. It should not all be fairly so minimize and dry, nonetheless.

Dark Phoenix made its strategy to the massive display screen amid a litany of setbacks. Originally slated to premiere in November 2018, its launch date was pushed again to February 2019 (instantly after the primary trailer was launched touting the November date), after which it was delayed once more to June (as a result of the February date conflicted with James Cameron’s Alita: Battle Angel). Bad take a look at screenings necessitated expensive reshoots, which led to the unique ending being modified and scaled down. Meanwhile, the Disney/Fox deal occurred throughout Dark Phoenix‘s manufacturing and the X-Men movie rights returned to Marvel in consequence. This meant that Dark Phoenix turned the ultimate movie and the top of Fox’s X-Men franchise – a significance it was by no means initially designed for.

Related: Deadpool 2 Spoiled Dark Phoenix’s Major Deaths

Also, Dark Phoenix‘s advertising definitely did not assist. It was solely within the final couple of weeks earlier than its launch that Dark Phoenix started to be touted as “the final chapter of the 19-year X-Men saga” the place “the X-Men would face their greatest enemy” (implying it was Jean when the actual villains have been Jessica Chastain’s alien Vuk and the D’Bari). This angle all of a sudden positioned Dark Phoenix because the fruits of the franchise, i.e. X-Men’s equal of Avengers: Endgame – however Dark Phoenix initially wasn’t meant to be the grand finale of the saga. Indeed, there have been plans for extra X-Men films after Dark Phoenix and its ending hints at another film that won’t be made now.

Dark Phoenix Is Far From The Worst X-Men Film

<!–[if IE 9]><![endif]–>

Some of the vitriol Dark Phoenix obtained is totally off base, and it is positively removed from the worst X-Men film, regardless of what the Rotten Tomatoes rating signifies. Between X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: The Last Stand (the 2 worst X-Men films) and X2: X-Men United and Logan (representing the sequence’ apex) the aim posts at both finish of the X-Men franchise have been already firmly established and Dark Phoenix lands someplace within the center. There have been far worse X-Men movies, by far, than Dark Phoenix, however Simon Kinberg‘s film is being taken to activity much more harshly for the sin of not being nice.

Dark Phoenix was originally conceived as two films, and we are going to by no means know if Kinberg’s aborted plans might need turned out higher. The ultimate movie has been modified on account of reshoots to the unique ending, which had an enormous battle on the United Nations and Jean turning into the Phoenix to repel an alien invasion. This was scrapped in favor of a scaled-down (however nonetheless very entertaining) battle on a practice. At one level the aliens were supposed to be the Skrulls, however that was modified to the D’Bari. Other alterations from what was seen within the trailers included Storm (Alexandra Shipp) becoming a member of Magneto’s Brotherhood together with Beast (Nicholas Hoult); within the ultimate movie Storm stays with the X-Men, although she nonetheless needs to cease Jean.

But even earlier than these adjustments, Dark Phoenix was (sadly) by no means going to be the X-Men franchise’s equal to Avengers: Endgame. Rather, Dark Phoenix was imagined to be a palate-cleanser from X-Men: Apocalypse, which followers rejected for being overblown and cartoonish. As a extra intimate story in regards to the X-Men and Jean Grey, Dark Phoenix was designed to play extra to the cleaning soap opera points of X-Men (and The Dark Phoenix Saga comics) to make it extra in regards to the characters than about sheer spectacle. This follows the instance of Logan, the emotion-packed sendoff for Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine.

Related: Dark Phoenix Improved On X-Men: The Last Stand (So Why Isn’t It A Better Movie?)

What Dark Phoenix Gets Right… And Wrong

<!–[if IE 9]><![endif]–>X-Men Dark Phoenix Trailer Space Crew

As a cinematic do-over of The Dark Phoenix SagaDark Phoenix nonetheless underwhelms, however the movie nonetheless does plenty of issues proper. Dark Phoenix‘s first act is its finest: Set in 1992, the X-Men are publicly adored superheroes, which is one thing film followers have not seen earlier than. Accompanied by an electrical score by Hans Zimmer, the X-Men’s outer area mission is the movie’s spotlight, with Nightcrawler (Kodi Smit-McPhee) proving himself invaluable as Jean is struck by the Phoenix Force. There’s additionally a enjoyable victory occasion (with a cameo by Dazzler) that lets the X-Men chill out and highlights the connection between Jean and Cyclops (Tye Sheridan). After Jean goes on a rampage, the motion shifts to Genosha and attracts Magneto (Michael Fassbender) into the fray. While the movie did Mystique (Jennifer Lawrence) no favors in the way she is awkwardly killed off, Dark Phoenix does expertly play into the shared historical past of Professor X (James McAvoy), Magneto, Mystique, and Beast that goes all the way in which again to 1962 in X-Men: First Class.

Jean’s torment by the Phoenix Force and Dark Phoenix‘s ending aren’t ultimate, but it surely does have the advantage of not having Jean die a second time. Instead, Jean chooses to regulate the Phoenix Force as a substitute of letting it overwhelm her by feeding off her rage and trauma; when Vuk tries to steal the Phoenix Force so the D’Bari can take over the world, Jean chooses to grow to be the Phoenix to guard the planet and the X-Men, whom she realizes are her true household. To destroy Vuk, Jean turns into a better type of life and transforms into the fiery Phoenix Force itself, which performs on the X-Men saga’s theme of evolution. Rather than being a tragic sufferer, Dark Phoenix permits Jean to decide on her future. Although the execution is muddled, a minimum of it is centered on Jean because the hero, reasonably than being about Wolverine having to kill the lady he loves, which was one among  X-Men: The Last Stand‘s biggest mistakes.

Overall, Dark Phoenix is a high-quality X-Men film with stable performances and some thrilling motion set items. It’s a significantly better movie than X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men Origins: Wolverine, though Dark Phoenix additionally does not attain the heights of X2: X-Men United, X-Men: Days of Future Past, or Logan. Just from a conceptual standpoint, nonetheless, Kinberg’s resolution to remake The Dark Phoenix Saga was his first mistake, as 13 years since X-Men: The Last Stand was too quickly for a do-over. Dark Phoenix was additionally following up X-Men: Apocalypse, which was not well-received, and the absence of Wolverine damage the movie’s drawing energy with mainstream audiences. As a first-time director, Kinberg does a first rate job general, however he makes questionable writing selections and visually, Dark Phoenix lacks the epic scale followers have grown accustomed to, particularly from the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Fans Are Just Waiting For The X-Men To Join The MCU

<!–[if IE 9]><![endif]–>

Disney’s purchase of the X-Men from Fox made the sensation that Dark Phoenix was a lame duck unavoidable – and that is one other main purpose why the movie flopped. At this level, most followers are glad to attend till the X-Men are rebooted and at last be part of the MCU. When Marvel Studios’ productions turned probably the most dominant superhero films on the planet, it solely highlighted the numerous flaws of the X-Men franchise. To be truthful, X-Men has additionally delivered a handful of one of the best superhero films ever, however Fox’s mutant saga has had as many misses as hits and their failures (which now contains Dark Phoenix) have been embarrassments.

Related: Everything We Know About The X-Men’s Movie Future After Dark Phoenix

X-Men, which launched eight years earlier than Iron Man, was at all times the MCU’s erratic older sibling. Simply put, Fox by no means ran the X-Men franchise with the identical type of long-range planning, excessive degree of consistency, and a focus to element that the MCU has. Now, followers not solely crave seeing Wolverine meet Spider-Man or Storm meet Black Panther however additionally they yearn to see the X-Men dealt with with the identical degree of dependable high quality that the Avengers get from Marvel Studios.

In the finish, Dark Phoenix‘s failure, sadly, ends Fox’s X-Men with a whimper reasonably than capping off its 19-year saga with a wonderful success. But maybe historical past will probably be form and can at some point regard Dark Phoenix as a reasonably good X-Men film that was shot down by not possible circumstances.

Next: Every X-Men Movie Ranked Worst To Best

Key Release Dates
  • X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019) launch date: Jun 07, 2019
  • New Mutants (2020) launch date: Apr 03, 2020